The not-so-crazy world of toddler breastfeeding

‘That’s it, I’ve become one of those crazy ladies who breastfeeds their walking toddler!’ I said to myself (tongue in cheek) as we walked back from our first La Leche League (LLL) toddler meeting yesterday. LLL is a network of mum-to-mum breastfeeding support groups, which exist in many countries across the globe. We meet to have a chat about breastfeeding and other things in life, and it’s a great way to share experiences and tips, and generally feel like you’re not the only one breastfeeding your baby/toddler. Once every 2 months the meeting is specifically aimed at those mums who are feeding their child into the second year of his/her life, and yesterday was the first of these ‘toddler meetings’ since Andrew and I fell into that description.

Both of us enjoying a feed before bedtime

When I first walked into an LLL coffee morning with my 4-week-old babe-in-arms, I admit I was surprised to see several mums breastfeeding toddlers who were 1 or 2 or even older. At that point I was really struggling with breastfeeding: Andrew was slow to gain weight, we were having to supplement with formula, and I was having a hard time reconciling in my head the fact that I desperately wanted to breastfeed him, I enjoyed having him so close and bonding with him in that way, but knew I wasn’t physically producing enough milk – the baby scales said it all. (If you haven’t read our breastfeeding story from the start, have a read of this previous post.) So I thought it would be amazing if we could make it to the NHS-recommended 6 months; it never even crossed my mind that we’d still be going beyond a year. I thought that I could never be, wouldn’t want to be, and wouldn’t even need to think about whether I should be, one of ‘those’ mums. How wrong I was. So it is with my tail between my legs that I come to write this post, looking back at how I judged others on that first LLL day.

In my defence though, I would say that I soon realised that these ladies were in fact lovely, intelligent, friendly and welcoming mums, and the initial feeling of surprise and awkwardness on my part soon faded. The vibes I was getting from the NHS, through contact with health professionals and reading the ‘Birth to Five’ book that everyone gets given, were that breast is best full stop, that formula feeding is OK if you’re a breastfeeding failure, and that mixed feeding is…no hang on, what on earth is that?!  On the contrary, LLL immediately made me feel welcome, accepting me into the group with open arms, despite the fact that I brought formula to the meetings. It did help that I used a supplementer rather than bottles though (again, see previous post), so I was in fact breastfeeding, just with a little extra help.

(NOTE: one of the lovely LLL ladies has brought it to my attention though a nice comment that this last sentence could be misinterpreted from what I meant. I did not mean that LLL would not have welcomed me if I had turned up with formula and bottles. On the contrary, I knew after I’d been that this was not true. What I meant was that this was my (and maybe a general?) preconception about breastfeeding support groups. I felt awkward at first, but soon realised I was wrong. I meant it helped me that I didn’t have to go with bottles the first time until my preconceptions were gone. Hope I didn’t give the wrong impression on this in the meantime.)

Every month (unless we were away), Andrew and I turned up at the regular meetings twice a month. I got so much moral support and helpful advice, and I believe the LLL ladies have played a big part in helping me continue to breastfeed until now. Was there any guilt tripping involved, like would I have felt bad about giving up when these ladies are so pro breastfeeding? Not at all. In fact I would say I would have felt less guilty about giving up in front of them and less of a failure than I would have done in front of many other people, including my midwife, GP and health visitor. And the reason? Because the ladies there know just how hard it can be, just how emotionally exhausting it can be when things aren’t going right, and how there is way more to it than simply getting food from mum to baby. That’s where the health professionals got me down – for them breastfeeding was all about Andrew gaining weight. And that’s where I came to realise, through LLL, that I could still have all the other amazing bits of breastfeeding, alongside the physical act of getting calories from mum (or formula tin) to baby.

It was very clear to me from the start that my friends at LLL are all intelligent ladies, who want to do the best for their child(ren) and have read up on breastfeeding and related issues. They’re not just feeding their babies beyond 6 months for no reason, or to be deliberately provocative to their numerous critics (believe me, we would rather not have to deal with criticism). They know that breastfeeding until the child weans him- or herself is normal when you step out of our society for a minute and look at things from a more global or human evolutionary perspective.

Did you know that the World Health Organisation recomends ‘exclusive breastfeeding up to 6 months of age, with continued breastfeeding along with appropriate complementary foods up to two years of age or beyond‘? Somewhere in the NHS recommendation on breastfeeding the second part of the WHO’s statement has got lost. I suspect too that the large increase in bottle feeding a couple of generations ago also played a part in changing our society’s view on what is ‘normal’ when it comes to the age we should wean a child. As a researcher myself, I always look for references in peer-reviewed publications when anyone makes a claim about something that should be tested with ‘scientific’ methods, and that includes breastfeeding. As well as being a mum-to-mum support network, LLL has many publications about various aspects of breastfeeding, all of which are backed up by referenced research conducted by scientists and health professionals around the world. This makes me 🙂

A quick search on the LLL international website for what is a ‘natural’ age that a child weans from breastfeeding gives an interesting article citing various studies. Some have suggested that a natural age is to do with when the child triples or quadruples their birth weight (average 27-30 months); others have suggested it’s to do with attaining one third of their adult weight (4 to 7 years); others have suggested it’s to do with our gestation length (i.e. 9 months) (average 4.5 years); others have suggested it’s to do with the eruption of adult molar teeth (around 5.5 years). In other words, quite a while then.

Look at how big he is - but not too big to snuggle up to mummy

That is not to say that I do not respect other mums’ decisions to either not breastfeed at all or to impose their own time-constraint on weaning. Every mum and baby pair is different, and believe me I know how hard it is to establish breastfeeding – it took us that first 6 months to really get going, so I totally understand why so many stop. (I think the words ‘give up’ sound too negative, and I don’t want to invoke feelings of failure because there is enough of that around as it is.) I also understand that not every mum enjoys breastfeeding so doesn’t want to carry on longer than she feels she has to, and that does not mean she is any less of a good mum. As I said we’re all different, with different personalities, different experiences, different situations and different ideas about what we think is the best thing to do at any given time.

In our case, one of the reasons why I love it so much now is that it was so hard back then – I appreciate good times more when I have a contrast with bad times. Ironically, if I hadn’t have had the problems at the start, I might not have gone to LLL and therefore might not have learnt that children self-wean when they are ready (this is often after when is generally acceptable in society), and I might have already weaned him. Every cloud has a silver lining. In a way, because it’s not always been for us just about ‘food’ for growth, it makes even more sense to me to carry on for as long as Andrew would like to get the comfort and pure mummy-time that he’s always got from it.

At the moment he feeds for about half an hour first thing in the morning (in bed with us so we all get to stay in bed longer – no bad thing all round), half an hour last thing in the evening before bed which sends him to sleep, sometimes in the night if he wakes (though he’s generally a very good sleeper), and sometimes in the day if he’s upset or tired. I know exactly when he wants to feed from me, because he’s very good at doing the milk ‘sign’ (we’ve done baby signing, I really must blog that one day) and pulling my top down! He must have a need for it, otherwise he wouldn’t ask for it. As a mum I want to meet that need for as long as necessary, because that’s my role in life, and I’m proud of it 🙂

And as it turns out, I’m not that crazy for feeling this way about toddler breastfeeding, when I talk with those who feel the same. Does anyone else have experience of breastfeeding beyond a year? Do you think it’s too old to still be breastfeeding? I’d love to hear what you think, whether you agree with me or think I’m crazy.

10 thoughts on “The not-so-crazy world of toddler breastfeeding”

  1. Hi! I found you via Brit Mums.What an amazing journey for you both.I too struggled with all my 3 and weaned and variable ages (10 1/2 months, 17 months and 3 1/2 years.).I couldn’t of got through breastfeeding without the support of my local breastfeeding group either.I hope you both continue as long as you both are happy to. 😀

    1. Thanks so much for the comment Aly 🙂 Yes I think that’s the point – to continue as long as both of us are happy to. Glad you also found support, as I don’t think all mums are lucky enough to find it at the right time.

  2. Great post! As you know I had to stop breastfeeding due to all the problems we were having with suspected oversupply. All the info you sent and the support I had (online more than my local support group – the Health Visitor there just said “oh maybe he’s just traumatising your nipples when he chomps down, you’ll just have to deal with it” and all the other mums just looked at me in disbelief!) was amazing, but in the end it just didn’t work out for us. I didn’t even realise how bad my blocked ducts were until someone mentioned that they had problems with blocked ducts and “once I had one the size of a golf ball”. That totally blew me away because I had a blocked duct the size of a golf ball every other day, and several smaller ones in between!! I was either in constant fear of the next one occurring or in agony trying to get one to clear and Oscar was either screaming with hunger or choking on a letdown that was far too fast for him. He was a totally different baby once we switched to formula. I was totally exhausted by that point and it took me weeks to reduce my supply and switch him over, so I ended up just “giving up”. And I feel those words are right *for me* because I did just want nothing more to do with it. Until several weeks later, that is, but at that point Oscar fussed because he was used to getting much more than I was producing and now I think I’ve pretty much lost my supply. And that makes me so sad as I miss being able to give him those feeds and would have loved to continue giving him feeds until we were both ready to stop.

    I have a friend who breastfed for 22 months with her first baby. I have another friend who breastfed for 7 years. I have 2 friends who had similar problems to you but had no support so felt they were just unable to do it. And I have a friend and my mum who both felt breastfeeding just wasn’t right for them. So I find it incredible that if I know so many people within my own small network of friends who have chosen such different routes, why then does the NHS and society seem to think there is just one way to do it? Um, I think that last sentence is a total shambles grammatically, but I couldn’t quite get my brain to work it out, sorry!

    Anyway, that was a long comment to say this is a great post 🙂 and thanks for being so supportive of others. (Oh, and we’re doing baby sign too, along with German and Tim has now started to try introducing a bit of French to Oscar too, so we’ll have lots to talk about soon!!)

    1. Thanks for the comment Amanda. I know what you mean about there being so many different breastfeeding routes/stories (maybe I would even say every single case is unique), that it’s hard to treat it as ‘one’ thing that you do or don’t. I’ve definitely learnt that it’s not black and white like that. I respect every mum’s decision to do what she wants to do and feels is right *for her*. I’d just like to offer support to mums who would like it, no matter what their decision ultimately is, that’s none of my business. Fun times with the languages – Andrew recognises words in three languages, like ball and mouse are his favourite at the moment, so exciting to watch!

  3. Lovely post, Ruth! Mothers are welcome at LLL meetings with any kind of feeding method and issue. LLL Leaders are there to help. Some come with bottles, some with sandwiches, all are mothers who need support – and if they want to talk about breastfeeding and how to avoid or overcome challenges, how to use breastfeeding as a way of mothering their little ones – all are welcome! The LLLGB Helpline is available 24/7 for mothers too, see (for other countries, see

    1. Thanks Rachel. Sorry I should have put a bit more about LLL in general. Hope what I said was good enough, tried to get across that I felt very welcome no matter what and that I knew you ladies understood my problems and were there to help. Your comment certainly improves my post, thank you! (ah just noticed my link doesn’t work – that’s no good! think I put – a mix of the 2)

    2. Sorry again, just realised the bit I wrote about formula and bottles sounded awful. Must learn to re- and re-read posts before publishing, I’ve added a note and updated the post, along with proper links. Hope that’s all a bit more positive now 🙂

  4. All 3 of mine lasted about 2.5 years and then one morning woke up and thought yuck! weird. I was always lucky to be surrounded by friends/ family who were supportive, as there was alway very little outside help.

    1. Thanks for your comment Liz 🙂 Yes I think having supportive family and friends makes a big difference in many cases, including ours. We were very lucky to get help from the LLL group, but that’s probably also to do with where we live, and in general I think there’s not enough outside help (from what others have said).

Leave a Reply to Rachel O'Leary Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *